REVIEWER EVALUATION FORM

(Pedagogy / Professional Education)

2. Relevance and Scientific Significance*

Please evaluate using a 1–5 scale (1 – low, 5 – high):

3. Problem Statement and Research Aim*

Score (1–5):

4. Theoretical and Methodological Framework*

Score (1–5):

5. Research Methodology and Design*

Score (1–5):

6. Scientific Novelty*

Score (1–5):

7. Practical Significance*

Score (1–5):

8. Practical Significance*

Score (1–5):

9. Conclusions*

Score (1–5):

10. References*

Score (1–5):

11. Final Reviewer Assessment (circle one)*

12. Detailed comments and recommendations for the author*

 

13. General comments and recommendations:*